Are you tired of constantly shelling out money for expensive crafting supplies? Do you often find yourself running out of Mod Podge in the middle of a project? Well, fear not. I have some exciting news for all my fellow crafters out there.
It turns out that your trusty bottle of Elmer’s glue may just be the perfect substitute for Mod Podge. Yes, you heard it right – Elmer’s glue. Still skeptical? Keep reading to discover why Elmer’s glue is a game-changer for all your crafting needs.
So, can i use elmers glue in place of mod podge?
Yes, you can use Elmer’s glue instead of Mod Podge, but they have different ingredients and uses:
- Elmer’s glue: Can be used as a substitute for Mod Podge. Elmer’s glue can be thinned with water and used for decoupage. However, Elmer’s glue doesn’t stick as well as Mod Podge, and it can leave more air bubbles. Elmer’s glue will also yellow over time.
- Mod Podge: A popular choice for decoupaging because it can be used for gluing, sealing, and finishing. Mod Podge contains polyvinyl acetate type II, which is also the main ingredient in white school glue and wood glue. Mod Podge can be applied directly to paper with or without dilution. The water in PVA glue can cause the ink from inkjet printers to bleed, so Mod Podge is recommended for mounting inkjet printed sheets.
In this blog post, I will also share some helpful tips and tricks on how to effectively use Elmer’s glue as a substitute for Mod Podge. Say goodbye to constantly restocking your supply of Mod Podge and hello to a versatile and budget-friendly alternative – Elmer’s glue. Let’s get our craft on.
Table of Contents
What Is Mod Podge?
Crafting is a popular hobby, and one of the essential supplies for this activity is sealant. A well-known product for this purpose is Mod Podge, which is made from a combination of polyvinyl acetate (PVA) and other additives like resin and plasticizers. Mod Podge is a water-based product that is exclusively manufactured by Plaid Enterprises and is trademarked under this name.
In contrast, Elmer’s glue is another well-known brand of white school glue that is commonly used for adhering paper and other lightweight materials. Like Mod Podge, it is also a water-based product made from PVA, but it lacks the additional additives found in Mod Podge. This difference in composition makes Elmer’s glue an adhesive rather than a sealant.
One of the significant distinctions between Mod Podge and Elmer’s glue lies in their intended use. While Mod Podge is exclusively designed as a sealant, it can provide either a glossy or matte finish depending on the type used. It is widely used to seal and protect various crafting projects, such as decoupage, collage, and scrapbooking. On the other hand, Elmer’s glue is primarily used as an adhesive for paper-based projects and may not provide the same level of protection as Mod Podge.
Cost-wise, Elmer’s glue is often seen as a more budget-friendly alternative to Mod Podge. However, it may not be suitable for all crafting projects, especially those that require water-resistant or outdoor use. While it can mimic the sealing properties of Mod Podge when mixed with water, it may not have the same durability and longevity.
PVA Glue As A Mod Podge Substitute
PVA glue, also known as Polyvinyl Acetate, can serve as an alternative to Mod Podge, but it may not achieve the same outcome and durability. Let’s delve deeper into the advantages and limitations of using PVA glue as a substitute for Mod Podge.
Benefits:
- PVA glue is more affordable and more accessible than Mod Podge, making it a cost-effective option for any crafting project.
- Being water-based and non-toxic, it is safe to use for all age groups.
- PVA glue can be used both as an adhesive and a sealant, making it a versatile choice for various crafting needs.
- It has a robust bonding capability and works well on different surfaces like wood, glass, metal, and more.
- When dried, PVA glue is transparent, making it perfect for projects that require a see-through or translucent finish.
Limitations:
- PVA glue lacks the unique ingredients found in Mod Podge that give it its distinct properties like sealing and finishing.
- It may not provide the same glossy finish as Mod Podge, especially when used as a sealant.
- Over time, PVA glue may turn yellow and flake off, affecting the appearance and durability of the project.
- It may not be as effective on all surfaces as Mod Podge.
Polyurethane In Place Of Mod Podge
When it comes to decoupage projects, polyurethane is often used as a sealant. However, it is not a suitable replacement for Mod Podge when it comes to its gluing properties. While polyurethane can be used as a sealant, it does not have the same adhesive abilities as Mod Podge.
It’s essential to note that Mod Podge has a unique formula specifically designed for gluing, sealing, and finishing projects, making it the optimal choice for crafting purposes.
| Properties | Mod Podge | Polyurethane |
| Gluing agent | Yes | No |
| Sealant | Yes | Yes |
| Finisher | Yes | No |
| Specifically formulated for crafting projects | Yes | No |
| Suitable for various surfaces (wood, cardboard, glass, etc.) | Yes | Yes (as a sealant) |
| Waterproof option available | Yes | No (as a sealant) |
Polyurethane may be used as a substitute for Mod Podge as a sealant for decoupage projects.
However, it lacks the adhesive properties and finish of Mod Podge. Additionally, Mod Podge offers specific formulas for different types of projects, such as outdoor Mod Podge for waterproofing.
Replacing Mod Podge with polyurethane may result in less satisfactory and long-lasting results.
Making Your Own Mod Podge
Creating your own Mod Podge with Elmer’s glue is a simple and cost-effective way to enhance your crafting projects. With just a few materials and easy steps, you can have your homemade Mod Podge ready to use in no time.
| Step 1: | Gather your materials | – Elmer’s glue – Water – Mixing bowl or container – Measuring cup – Spoon or stirring stick – Sealable container for storage (optional) |
| Step 2: | Mix the glue and water | – Equal parts of Elmer’s glue and water – Thoroughly mix together |
| Step 3: | Adjust the consistency (optional) | Add more glue for a thicker mixture or more water for a thinner one |
| Step 4: | Transfer to a sealable container (optional) | Prevent mixture from drying out and becoming unusable |
| Step 5: | Use and store as needed | Apply to project, let dry completely before adding additional layers or using a sealer on top Store leftover mixture in sealable container for future use |
Sealing Homemade Mod Podge
When it comes to sealing your homemade mod podge made with Elmer’s glue, the most effective method is to use either a clear acrylic sealer spray or a brush-on varnish. This will not only protect your project from any potential moisture damage, but also give it a beautiful glossy finish that is reminiscent of store-bought mod podge.
One option for sealing your homemade mod podge is by using a clear acrylic sealer spray. Simply apply a few coats of the spray over your project, letting it dry between each coat. This will create a protective barrier that will prevent any moisture from damaging your project, while also giving it a glossy finish that is sure to impress.
Another option is to use a brush-on varnish. This involves using a small brush to apply the varnish over your project, making sure to cover every inch of the surface. Similar to the spray, you may need to apply multiple coats for the best results. The varnish will act as a sealant, keeping your homemade mod podge safe from moisture and giving it a glossy sheen that will elevate your project to the next level.
Will PVA Glue Turn Yellow Over Time?
While possible, using PVA glue as a long-term substitute is not recommended as it will eventually turn yellow over time. This is due to the properties of PVA glue, which is made from polyvinyl acetate and water.
| Substitute | Is it possible to use it as a substitute for Mod Podge? | Will it eventually turn yellow over time? |
| Clear nail polish | No | N/A |
| PVA glue (diluted with water) | Yes | Yes |
| Elmer’s Glue-All (properly diluted) | Yes | No |
While PVA glue can be used as a temporary alternative in urgent situations, it is not recommended for extended use. This is because PVA glue has different properties compared to Mod Podge, which is specifically designed for decoupage projects. It should also be noted that PVA glue should not be confused with white glue or school glue, as its bonding properties are stronger.
The Best Substitutes For Mod Podge
For individuals who may not have access to or prefer not to use Mod Podge, there are various substitutes available for crafting and DIY projects. These alternatives include PVA glue, Elmer’s glue, and painting mediums like matte medium or gloss medium.
PVA glue, also known as white glue or school glue, is a popular alternative to Mod Podge for its quick drying time and versatility in crafting projects. It can be easily found at most craft and art supply stores and is often more affordable than Mod Podge. However, it is important to properly dilute and seal PVA glue as it may turn yellow over time and cause deterioration of certain materials.
Elmer’s glue is another readily available option for Mod Podge. It can be used alone or mixed with water and gloss varnish for a shinier finish. Similar to PVA glue, it is crucial to apply the appropriate amount of glue and ensure the surface is clean and dry for optimal results.
Painting mediums such as matte medium or gloss medium can also be combined with acrylic paints to create a sealant for crafting projects. This alternative offers a range of creative possibilities and allows for customization of the finish depending on the project.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Elmer’s glue is a game-changing substitute for Mod Podge that can save you both money and time in your crafting endeavors.
Its affordability, versatility, and strong bonding capabilities make it a worthy alternative for various projects. However, it’s important to note that while it can mimic the sealing properties of Mod Podge when mixed with water, it may not have the same durability and longevity.
So say farewell to constantly restocking your supply of Mod Podge and welcome a budget-friendly and versatile alternative – Elmer’s glue.
