Do you find yourself constantly running out of Modge Podge in the middle of a crafting project? Or maybe you’re tired of spending money on expensive supplies. Well, look no further because we may have found the perfect solution for you – Elmer’s glue. That’s right, the same glue that you used in elementary school could potentially be a substitute for the popular crafting adhesive.
So, can i use elmers glue instead of modge podge?
Yes, you can use Elmer’s glue instead of Mod Podge in some craft projects. Elmer’s Glue All is a brand of PVA glue, which is the same as regular Mod Podge, which is a diluted permanent white glue. Both should dry clear and glossy if not too thick.
In this blog post, we will delve deeper into the potential use of Elmer’s glue as a substitute for Modge Podge. So grab your glue and get ready to discover a new world of possibilities in your crafting journey.
Table of Contents
What Is Modge Podge?
Crafting and DIY projects often require the use of adhesives, and two popular options are Modge Podge and Elmer’s glue. Although they serve similar purposes, these two products have different formulations. Let’s take a closer look at the differences between them.
Modge Podge is a versatile adhesive that also acts as a sealer and finisher. Its formulation includes PVA glue, water, and acrylic resins. This unique combination allows it to bond various materials such as paper, fabric, and wood while providing a protective topcoat. It’s a safe option for children, and it comes in different finishes like matte, glossy, and satin.
In contrast, Elmer’s glue is primarily made of PVA and is environmentally friendly. It’s known for its strong bonding capabilities, making it a popular choice for school projects. While it can also be used for basic crafting, it may not offer the same sealing properties as Modge Podge.
One significant difference between Modge Podge and Elmer’s glue is their water-resistance. Modge Podge is more resistant to water than Elmer’s glue, making it ideal for outdoor or moisture-exposed items. However, adding water to Elmer’s glue can help mimic the sealing properties of Modge Podge to some extent.
So, Modge Podge provides more versatility with its ability to act as both an adhesive and a sealer. However, for basic crafting projects, Elmer’s glue can be a cost-effective substitute. Both adhesives are easy to use, non-toxic, and suitable for various materials. And when faced with a lack of Modge Podge, Elmer’s glue can be a resourceful alternative.
What Is Elmer’s Glue?
Elmer’s glue and Modge Podge are two popular water-based adhesives commonly used in arts and crafts. While they serve a similar purpose, they have different formulations that make them unique in their own way.
Modge Podge is a three-in-one adhesive that acts as a sealer, super glue, and finish. Its composition includes polyvinyl acetate (PVA), water, resin, and mineral oil. On the other hand, Elmer’s glue contains only PVA and water.
One of the main differences between these two adhesives is their drying finish. Modge Podge dries clear, making it suitable for use as a sealer or finish on various surfaces. It also has increased water resistance, making it ideal for outdoor projects or items that may come in contact with moisture. Elmer’s glue, on the other hand, dries opaque and is not recommended for use as a sealer or finish due to its lack of clear drying.
When it comes to usage, Modge Podge is more versatile as it can be used on paper, fabrics, thin wood, and other porous materials that require sealing or finishing. Elmer’s glue is better suited for basic arts and crafts projects involving bonding materials such as thin wood, paper, fabrics, and cardboard.
Both adhesives are non-toxic and safe for children to use at school or home. However, Modge Podge may be a better choice for younger children due to its versatility and easy clean-up with soap and water.
Differences Between Modge Podge and Elmer’s Glue
When it comes to crafting projects, choosing the right adhesive can make all the difference. Two popular options are Modge Podge and Elmer’s Glue, but what sets them apart?
Let’s explore the main differences between these two adhesives, from their formulations to their effectiveness in different projects.
Formulation:
Modge Podge is a unique three-in-one adhesive that combines PVA glue, water, and other ingredients such as resin. This formulation gives it a versatile edge, allowing it to serve as a sealer, super glue, and finish all in one.
On the other hand, Elmer’s Glue only contains PVA glue and water, making it a more basic adhesive. This difference in composition means that Modge Podge is better suited for various crafting projects involving different materials such as paper, fabrics, and puzzles.
Versatility:
Thanks to its unique formulation, Modge Podge is more versatile than Elmer’s Glue. Not only can it act as a regular adhesive for lightweight materials like paper, but it can also provide water resistance for outdoor decorations or coasters.
It can even handle heavier materials like wood or metal due to its super glue capabilities. Additionally, Modge Podge can be used as a finish to give projects a glossy or matte appearance. Conversely, Elmer’s Glue is best used for simple projects with lightweight materials.
Effectiveness in Crafting Projects:
The versatility of Modge Podge makes it more effective in various crafting projects compared to Elmer’s Glue. Its water-based sealer capabilities make it ideal for outdoor decorations or coasters that require water resistance.
Its versatility also allows for a stronger hold on heavier materials like wood or metal. On the other hand, Elmer’s Glue is not as strong and should only be used for lightweight projects. It also lacks the same level of water resistance as Modge Podge.
Advantages of Using Elmer’s Glue Instead of Modge Podge
When it comes to crafting projects, many crafters prefer using Elmer’s glue instead of Modge Podge for several reasons. These advantages make it a popular choice among craft enthusiasts.
| Advantage | Description |
| Widely available and affordable | Elmer’s glue is a household name and can be found in most stores at an affordable price, making it easily accessible for crafters. |
| Dries clear without yellow tint | Unlike Modge Podge, Elmer’s glue will not leave a yellow tint on surfaces after drying, ensuring a clean and professional finish. |
| Easy clean-up with soap and water | Elmer’s glue is water-soluble, making it easy to clean up with just soap and water. This is especially useful when working with children. |
| Provides added texture and dimension | When used as a decoupage medium, Elmer’s glue can add texture and dimension to projects, creating a unique and eye-catching result. |
| Can be used as a substitute for Modge Podge | If Modge Podge is not available, Elmer’s glue can be diluted with water to create a similar consistency and used as a substitute. |
| Can be sealed for added protection | To make projects more durable, Elmer’s glue can be sealed with varnish or clear coat to provide added protection against wear and tear. |
| Longer shelf life | Unlike Modge Podge, Elmer’s glue has a longer shelf life, making it a more practical and cost-effective option for those who do not frequently use decoupage mediums. |
Aside from these benefits, Elmer’s glue also offers the advantage of being a versatile medium that can be used in various crafting projects. It provides a budget-friendly and easy-to-use alternative to Modge Podge, making it a preferred choice among beginners and experienced crafters alike.
However, it is important to note that Modge Podge still has its own strengths and is more suitable for advanced or specialized projects.
Disadvantages of Using Elmer’s Glue Instead of Modge Podge
While Elmer’s glue can serve as a substitute for Modge Podge in crafting projects, it may not provide the same level of effectiveness and durability. It is important to consider the potential consequences of using Elmer’s glue instead of Modge Podge, including:
| Disadvantages of Using Elmer’s Glue Instead of Modge Podge | Description |
| Reduced Water-Resistance | Elmer’s glue may not hold up as well when exposed to water compared to Modge Podge. |
| Limited Use for Outdoor Projects | Elmer’s glue may not be suitable for outdoor projects due to its lower water-resistance. |
| Potential Limitations for Specific Projects | Elmer’s glue may not be suitable for all types of projects, especially those involving paper or fabric. |
Tips for Using Elmer’s Glue as a Substitute for Modge Podge
Elmer’s glue is a versatile alternative to Mod Podge for various crafting projects. It provides convenience and cost-effectiveness while still offering a similar sealing effect.
However, it is crucial to note that Elmer’s glue may not be as water-resistant as Mod Podge, so it is not recommended for outdoor or moisture-exposed items.
To effectively use Elmer’s glue as a substitute for Mod Podge, here are some tips to keep in mind:
Mixing Ratio:
| Elmer’s Glue | Water |
| 1 part | 1 part |
The key to successfully using Elmer’s glue as a substitute is to mix it with water in equal parts. This will help replicate the consistency and sealing properties of Mod Podge.
Application:
| Tools: | Suggested Technique: |
| Foam brush or sponge | Spread the mixture evenly onto your project using a foam brush or sponge. |
After mixing the glue and water, use a foam brush or sponge to spread the mixture onto your project. Make sure to apply it evenly and cover all areas that need sealing.
Drying Time:
| Drying Time: | Additional Layers: |
| Dry completely within 24 hours | Apply additional layers if necessary after the first layer has dried completely. |
It is crucial to allow the Elmer’s glue mixture to dry completely before handling the project or applying additional layers. This ensures that the glue has fully sealed and will not smudge or come off during the crafting process.
Optional Topcoat:
| Topcoat: | Application: |
| Clear acrylic spray | Apply a topcoat of clear acrylic spray to increase durability and water-resistance. |
For added durability and water-resistance, you can choose to use a topcoat of clear acrylic spray after the Elmer’s glue mixture has dried completely. This will help protect your project from moisture and make it more durable.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while Modge Podge may be the go-to choice for many crafters, Elmer’s glue can also be a viable option in certain projects.
Its affordability and widespread availability make it a popular substitute, and with some simple tweaks, it can provide similar results.
However, it is important to keep in mind that Elmer’s glue may not offer the same level of water-resistance and versatility as Modge Podge.
